My husband complained that all my soaps smelled too girly. Point taken - so I found some fragrances that were more manly, or at least gender neutral.
Woodsman smells like autumn leaves and rum. Mmmmm!
All my soaps are made with an old-fashioned lye soap recipe (just like great-grandma used to make), but I replace some of the water in the recipe with milk from goats raised on my farm in western Kentucky. Goat milk gives the soap a neutral pH level, so it won't dry out your skin.  The remaining ingredients are a yummy list of oils and butters - coconut, cocoa, shea, and so on.  Almost good enough to eat! (Please don't....really)
Note: This soap used to be called Woodsman, however due to a conflict with another company who has copyrighted "Woodsman" for their beard oil, we had to change it's name.  It's now Rum Runner, and we added a little actual rum to the soap for good measure!